Back to articles

Negative Bond Yields Infect the U.K.

The U.K. government achieved a dubious milestone on Wednesday, May 20. It sold its first ever batch of negative-yield bonds.

In 2016 — when Brexit took markets by surprise — a one-month U.K. treasury bill went negative. But May 20 was Britain’s first time for a conventional longer-term bond.

The offering was for 3.8 billion pounds worth of three-year gilts (debt securities issued by the British government). The auction was more than twice oversubscribed, with 8.1 billion pounds worth of submitted orders, at a yield of negative 0.003%.

We explained how negative yields work in “The Mechanics of Negative Interest Rates.”

To quickly recap, yield is a function of the bond price. If the price paid is high enough, the yield goes negative, which means the buyer loses money if they hold the bond to maturity.

So why would buyers purchase three-year U.K. gilts at a negative yield? For three possible reasons.

One reason is speculative. If the yield goes even more negative, which means the bond price goes higher, the early negative-yield buyers might expect to make money on the trade.

You are only guaranteed to lose money on a negative-yield bond if you hold it to maturity. If you sell the bond prior to maturity (i.e. trade it) at a higher price than you paid — that is to say, at an even more negative yield — you can make a profit. Rather than “buy low and sell high,” this is a game of “buy high and sell higher.”

So, buyers of three-year gilts at a slightly negative yield might be anticipating even more negative yields, by way of higher gilt prices, in the near future.

This could happen because the Bank of England (BOE) has embarked on a “quantitative easing” (QE) program to help fund record levels of borrowing from the UK government as a result of the pandemic. If the BOE is a steady buyer of gilts, yields could go even more negative.

Another potential reason is fear of outright deflation.

Institutional buyers will sometimes buy sovereign bonds, at almost any price, for a lack of preferable alternatives. If the British economy is staring deflation in the face, as the result of its worst economic crisis in 300-plus years, gilts that lose a tiny smidge of capital (via negative return) could outshine other UK assets at risk of losing a lot.

A third possible reason is anticipation of the BOE “going negative” on purpose.

If this happened, the BOE would announce negative rates as a function of official policy, and deliberately target a below-zero yield at the short end of the curve. (The current UK “base rate,” comparable to the U.S. Fed Funds rate, is a notch above zero at 0.1%.)

The Bank of England, like the U.S. Federal Reserve, has pushed back hard on the notion of negative rates as official policy. They want you to believe it will never happen.

But even if the BOE and the Fed hate the idea, the most realistic stance is “you never know.”

If the overall picture gets deflationary enough — meaning that overall price levels outside of shortage-impacted areas start to collapse — negative rates might become a necessity, in order to avoid a deflationary downward spiral.

Then, too, if longer-term bond yields go significantly negative across the board, which could happen on its own, the BOE and Fed might be forced to follow suit. 

None of this is good news for expectations of quick recovery. Rather, the UK seeing its first-ever negative bond yield adds to the bearish message of the U.S. bond market.

Then, too, if the U.S. 10-year Treasury yield (currently at 0.70%) goes negative in the coming months, it would serve as a deflationary warning siren — and could trigger even wilder “printing press” type measures from the Federal Reserve.


Related content

Hong Kong’s Rage is the Harbinger of a Multi-Decade U.S.-China Cold War

November 18, 2019TradeSmith Research Team

On June 4, 1989, the Tiananmen Square Massacre occurred. On that dark day, the Chinese government declared martial law and sent in tanks and troops to put down student-led demonstrations. Westerners recall the iconic image of “tank man,” the lone protester standing in front of a line of tanks. What is less well-known is that, in the massacre that occurred less than 24 hours earlier, somewhere between several hundred and several thousand protesters were killed (and thousands more wounded). Three

The Pain for Tech Stocks is Only Just Beginning

March 9, 2021John Banks

The bursting of the tech bubble has taken down the Nasdaq, but left the Dow intact. This has created the greatest divergence between the Dow and the Nasdaq since 1993. March 8 was “the first time since 1993 that the Dow rose and closed within 1% of a record,” Bloomberg reports, “while the tech-heavy gauge was down more than 10% from its high.” As we’ve explained at length in these pages, silly-season tech valuations were a byproduct of the implied