We did a double take when we saw that Whole Paycheck, er, Whole Foods Market demand is trending up 98% year-over-year (YoY) on a 30-day average.
So much for consumers seeking less expensive grocery alternatives.
As we learned from this week’s inflation reading, even with lower gas prices, inflation is still a beast. So, with food prices climbing faster than they have in 43 years, why aren’t shoppers avoiding the already pricey Whole Foods?
We dug deeper and discovered:
- Whole Foods’ more affluent customer base is largely unaffected by today’s inflationary pressures (no surprise there).
But…
- Those who ARE affected aren’t switching stores — they’re switching to private label brands.
![]() |
In recognition of the tightened budgets of millions of American households, even high-end grocers like Whole Foods are expanding their assortment of generic brands.
Here at our local Whole Foods in Louisville, a dozen 365-branded eggs go for $3.39. A dozen of the Vital Farms national brand eggs? $7.49. And that’s the sale price!
Bottom line: With price mattering more than it has in years, brand switching is well underway.
![]() |
Consumer mentions of shopping for private label (or generic) brands reached all-time highs in August.
Across all major retail channels, Americans bought nearly $200 billion of private label brands last year, a record that will likely be beat this year.
Let’s dive into some of the trends shaping this major shift in consumer behavior.
1. No-Name Brands Are Making a Name for Themselves
As inflation drags on, name brands are falling out of favor and generic products are gaining popularity.
LikeFolio’s proprietary consumer analytics show that social media is really concerned about the affordability of food. Mentions of the topic are up more than 200% YoY.
And with wage growth stagnant, more people are turning to private label brands. Mentions of these less expensive goods have doubled since last year.
And it’s not just food and beverages. Consumers are looking to stretch the dollar by purchasing cheaper household essentials and personal care items too.
![]() |
Of course, there is an assumed trade-off in quality and familiarity when trading down to a store brand. The packaging looks foreign and sometimes the taste is different.
At this point, people don’t seem to care.
Grocery stores are on board with the private label craze, capitalizing on the current environment by appealing to shoppers’ hankering for value.
Marketing campaigns like those run by Save A Lot are pitting national brands and store brands against each other. Savings and money-back guarantees are highlighted to get shoppers to try in-house products.
![]() |
According to the Private Label Manufacturers Association (PLMA), store brands command approximately 18% of grocery market share.
That’s good news for grocery store operators, because proprietary brands form the core of food retail strategy. Simply put, they give the retailer more control. Everything from the ingredients to the packaging to the supply chain is owned by the retailer (or the wholesaler), and this results in higher margins. Yes, prices are lower, but costs are much lower.
And apparently, some store brands aren’t so bad after all.
Consumer interest in private labels goes beyond the savings. Across social media, people are discussing how certain products are just as good if not better than comparable national brands.
![]() |
Could it really be about more than just price?
2. National Brands Are in a Real Battle
The Food Industry Association’s “Power of Private Brands 2022” study found that more than 40% of private-brand shoppers are buying the generic stuff because they like the taste or quality.
Sustainability was found to be a significant factor as well. Selling points like “resealable packaging” and being “better for the planet” are giving shoppers (and especially the younger generations) more reason to lean toward private labels.
Our tracking of consumer mentions of products made from sustainable materials has been trending higher for some time and is currently up 55% YoY.
![]() |
Make no mistake, though. Price matters most.
Value and relative cost were the top reasons given for going private in the study.
So, with consumers now more aware of the value and benefits of store brands, which retailers are cashing in?
![]() |
Kroger: Simple Truth
- Purchase Intent mentions are up 21% YoY.
- In fiscal year 2021 (FY21), Simple Truth natural and organic product sales grew 20% to more than $3 billion.
- Over 1.4 million households tried Simple Truth plant-based products.
Costco: Kirkland Signature
- Purchase Intent mentions are up 17% YoY.
- FY21 Kirkland Signature brand merchandise sales were up 14% to $59 billion (and represented 30% of total sales).
- Costco plans to make private label products a bigger part of its sales mix.
Walmart: Great Value
- Purchase Intent mentions are up 17% YoY.
- Great Value is one of several private label store brands at Walmart. (Others include Equate, Faded Glory, George, Holiday Time, and Mainstays.)
- Walmart’s 6.5% comparative sales growth last quarter got a strong contribution from private brand sales.
As demand for generic products picks up, demand for some popular national brands is losing steam.
On a long-term basis, Purchase Intent mentions of Lay’s, Pepsi, and even mainstream cereals are down.
This is putting pressure on name-brand companies to lower prices—or risk losing shelf space. But with their input and logistics costs on the rise, price cuts seem to be a last resort.
For now, the big dogs are leaning on their strong brand recognition and product innovation to fend off generic competition.
The CEO of Conagra Brands recently stated:
“We believe the data shows that consumers are finding comfort in the quality, reliability and familiarity that national brands provide, particularly modernized brands like those in our portfolio.”
This is probably true to some extent. Still, we wonder: Are consumers’ budgets finding comfort in the higher price tags on Birds Eye, Duncan Hines, and Healthy Choice products?
This brings us to Kroger.
3. Kroger Is Killing It
Kroger’s Simple Truth is not just an up-and-coming brand. It’s actually the world’s largest natural and organic brand by volume — national and store brands included!
Not bad for a brand that’s only been around less than 10 years.
Kroger operates 33 food processing plants, many of which produce its seven private brands, including Simple Truth. Around 30% of Kroger brands are manufactured at these facilities. Keeping much of this production in-house creates a major cost advantage — and is the reason why the company is going full speed ahead on private labels.
In an industry notorious for razor-thin margins, Kroger is getting the most out of its more profitable private brands. The company hauled in roughly $28 billion in private label sales last year (representing 20% of overall sales).
![]() |
At a time when inflated food prices are on many consumers’ minds, Kroger is experiencing increasing demand. Purchase Intent mentions are up 14% on a 90-day average. Value-minded shoppers are gravitating toward Kroger’s brands — and playing right into Kroger’s hands.
And with consumers growing increasingly comfortable with affordable store brands, there is more success to come. When you have a portfolio of private brands (four of which are billion-dollar brands) that is growing faster than national brands, it only makes sense to pour more money into this business.
In the grocery version of David versus Goliath, this latest battle of name-brand giants and store brands has only just begun.
The giants have yet to concede on price. But given the mounting success of private label brands, they may soon have to wave the white discount flag.







