Back to articles

The Investable Clue in Top 2022 Holiday Drink Preferences

Awkward white elephant gift exchanges and uncomfortable small talk with co-workers are signs that the holiday office party is back in full swing.

Executive coaching firm Challenger, Gray & Christmas Inc. found in a survey that 56.9% of companies were having an in-person holiday party this year, a 26.6% increase from last year.
Other than being an interesting tidbit, we’re looking at this as an investing clue.

What are people drinking this holiday season?

We’ve been keeping tabs on consumer sentiment around Brown-Forman Corp. (BF.B) and Constellation Brands Inc. (STZ) as two major alcoholic beverage players that have different offerings and business strategies.

LikeFolio Purchase Intent (PI) mentions for Brown-Forman are slightly up year-over-year (YoY) on a 30-day average.

The increase in purchase intent is also consistent with the company’s recent results, delivering double-digit sales growth in its latest earnings report. But the company did report gross margin declined, being driven by inflation, supply chain disruptions, and the negative effect of foreign exchange.

But we see Brown-Forman as a resilient company that is still growing in a tough economy.

BF.B demand is solid because consumers are engaging in more social events and its offerings are better aligned with current trends.

PI mentions for Constellation Brands, on the other hand, are down 33% YoY. And although the company is on a different fiscal calendar, its latest quarterly results were similar.

Sales were up 12%.

BF.B and STZ face the same macro headwinds and competitive pressures.

So, why the disparity in LF data?

It comes down to their respective drink menus.

BF.B’s brand portfolio skews heavily toward spirits and ready-to-drink (RTD) options, with some wine offerings in there as well.

STZ is all about beer and wine, with a few spirits mixed in.

Our proprietary data suggests consumers are growing tired of beer, as PI mentions for the core Corona Extra brand fell to a 10-year low in the September to November quarter.

STZ must overcome slowing beer interest and its lagging wine business.

Heading into the holiday season, consumer preferences are clearly shifting away from beer and wine and towards mixed drinks.

Given this trend, BF.B has the better sales mix and is likely to serve up stronger results in the coming quarters.

Here’s why.

Red, Red Wine

Wine & Spirits Wholesalers of America, otherwise known as WSWA, found that wine is struggling.

Wine depletions (that’s industry speak for the number of cases distributors sell to retailers) are down 6.7% year-to-date (YTD).

The wine industry has earned high praise for weathering the pandemic. But since wineries have reopened to tourists and locals, consumers seem to be losing their taste.

Can the holiday season spark a revival?

Probably not.

LikeFolio data around consumer wine brand mentions is not looking positive.

In fact, the short-term trend across several popular wine brands is decidedly negative.

Mentions of STZ’s core Robert Mondavi brand are down sharply on a 30-day average, falling 72%.

Brown-Forman’s Sonoma-Cutrer brand is also losing favor with a 67% decline, but that’s having less of an impact on its business right now since it is primarily popular in the summer.

A rare bright spot is STZ’s Woodbridge (up 19%), but most of its brands are hurting.

There’s a wine problem — and it’s not a great time to be a business that relies on wine for a good portion of its revenue.

Good Spirits

Known as a more discerning generation, millennials are more likely to bring a bottle of whiskey, rum, or vodka to a 2022 holiday party. And since millennials form a large part of the drinking population today, spirit-centric companies are in the best position to win.

Overall, it’s a resurgence in Jack Daniel’s that is driving growth at Brown-Forman. Our data confirms that consumer interest in the iconic whiskey brand is recovering.

Mentions are up 18% since mid-July.

The Jack Daniel’s family of brands is catching fire largely because of Tennessee Fire and Tennessee Honey. More options can create more fans.

Premium whiskey brands like BF.B’s Woodford Reserve and Old Forester are crushing it, with BF.B also doubling down on the premium theme by launching Jack Daniel’s Bonded and Jack Daniel’s Triple Mash.

BF.B is also on point in the RTD space. Consumers are craving convenience like never before and products like Jack Daniel’s cans and el Jimador New Mix RTD cans are winning.

Put it all together, and it’s easy to see why BF.B is crushing the battle of adult beverages.

Hard Seltzer Is a Hard Sell

We’d be amiss not to check in on hard seltzer. After all, it was one of the hottest beverage trends of 2021.

LikeFolio mentions of alcoholic seltzers are down 23% YoY and at a post-COVID low.

Consumers are moving on from what is shaping up to be a pandemic fad. Spirits and canned cocktails are more in demand because they offer variety, flavor, and convenience.

Brown-Forman is taking advantage of that shift in tastes with its product offerings.

Bottom line: The movement of going beyond beer and wine is progressing nicely with spirits and RTD cocktails leading the way.

Companies are shifting their portfolios accordingly and some are better positioned than others.

We like the trends we are seeing at Louisville-based Brown-Forman. We see its brands asserting industry leadership heading into the new year.

Related content

This Stock Surprised Me!

March 7, 2021Lisa Lenda

Investing in 2020 was all about spotting opportunities in companies benefitting from consumers staying close to home. ZM. PTON. ROKU. This year, we’re taking the flipside of this view to spot potential winners. What companies are positioned to thrive now that communities are finally opening back up? One name on our radar may surprise you: American Eagle (AEO). Not the airline, but the clothing retailer. We dug into real-time consumer data ahead of American Eagle Q4 earnings. And boy, was the data spot on. Here’s how we

Why I Didn’t Take 200% Profits on ROKU

August 7, 2021Lisa Lenda

I’ve been bullish on Roku (ROKU) for 2.5 years now, after first alerting clients to the opportunity in January 2019, with the stock trading just under $40/share. In that initial report, we cited the cord-cutting movement and Roku’s proven ability to maintain and grow its user base as primary drivers of future growth. The stock took off like a rocket from there, zooming higher by more than 200% in a matter of months. I have to admit, it’s always tempting

Healthy Energy Drinks Aren’t an Oxymoron. One Just Led Us to a Profit Opportunity.

July 24, 2022Chris Lillard

The day after tomorrow, our lead analyst, Mike Burnick, reveals his amazing retirement income-generation strategy that’s 17x more profitable than blue-chip dividends. This FREE 2022 Retirement Revolution event starts promptly at 8:00 p.m. on Tuesday. Click here to learn how to make money even when stocks are in decline — just like now. — Keith Kaplan This week, I stopped by my favorite smoothie shop for a post-workout recovery treat. While I was waiting, I scanned the macro-nutrient-packed snack items